Pleasanton

PleasantonCA.city — Tri-Valley neighborhood news with hometown heart.

Back to Pleasanton

District 3 hopefuls Gupta and Yee both back the hotel tax hike but part ways on the budget gap and PFAS

At a Sept. 29 forum, Reena Gupta pitched Pleasanton as a destination for global firms and events, while Jamie Yee said the deficit 'doesn't add up' and called for a long-term business plan.

Reese Hardy

October 6, 20262 min read

Candidates at a forum lectern - illustration, Jake Team LLC

The two candidates for Pleasanton City Council District 3 agree the city should raise its hotel tax and get the Stoneridge Shopping Center redevelopment moving, but they offered different diagnoses of the city's money problems and its water contamination at a recent forum, according to a Pleasanton Weekly account published Tuesday.

Reena Gupta, a small-business owner and business advocate, and Jamie Yee, a former Pleasanton school board trustee who works for the Alameda County Public Health Department, are running for the southwest Pleasanton seat now held by Julie Testa, who is challenging Mayor Jack Balch in the Nov. 3 election.

They spoke Sept. 29 at a Weekly-hosted forum in the council chambers at the Civic Center that drew a standing-room crowd.

Fire season

Both said the city must keep teaching residents to prepare for emergencies after the Little Fire, which burned about 1,000 acres southeast of the district on July 21. Gupta said she wants every household signed up for emergency alerts and every neighborhood to have mapped evacuation routes.

Yee said the Livermore-Pleasanton Fire Department is stretched thin by low staffing and suggested working with the East Bay Regional Park District on fire mitigation.

Money

Both support Measure HH, which would raise the hotel tax from 8% to 12% over two years. Gupta said "every penny counts" but noted that "a tax on an empty hotel room generates nothing," and argued the larger opportunity is drawing more visitors, conferences and weddings, along with companies from around the world.

She pledged to give her council stipend of about $1,321 a month to the Friends of the Pleasanton Library and said restoring services such as library hours should come first.

Yee said she wants to examine what caused the deficit, since property and sales tax revenue has been stable or slightly higher in recent years. "Something doesn't add up," she said. She also called for a long-term plan to attract businesses, saying rising rents are pushing out shops such as hair salons and auto repair.

Stoneridge and housing

The council adopted a framework in 2023 to turn Stoneridge and its surroundings into a mixed-use district, but little has happened since. Gupta urged the mall's owners to agree on a plan and said the city should offer the incentives they need. Yee said the city should "get out of the way of the developers."

Yee also said the city should revisit its inclusionary zoning rules and focus on housing young adults can afford, while Gupta said new housing must be well placed and scaled with traffic, water and schools in mind.

Water

On PFAS, the so-called forever chemicals found in the city's groundwater, Gupta said the planned new wells with Zone 7 should not stop the city from exploring technology to restore its contaminated wells. Yee said the city has made strong progress on PFAS but, like Gupta, named rising water rates as a priority.

Sources

pleasantonweekly.com

Share

Reese Hardy

Reese Hardy writes about community life, schools, public safety, and local events in Pleasanton.

Related Stories

More in California