Pleasanton

PleasantonCA.city — Tri-Valley neighborhood news with hometown heart.

Back to California

Governor candidates split on dams, storage and the Delta tunnel as California braces for an El Nino winter

With an El Nino winter ahead, CalMatters compared the governor candidates: Steve Hilton backs Sites Reservoir and a higher Shasta Dam but opposes the Delta tunnel, while Xavier Becerra says he will listen and keeps the tunnel on the table.

Reese Hardy

October 11, 20262 min read

California Water Policy - illustration, Jake Team LLC

The two candidates for governor on the Nov. 3 ballot are taking very different approaches to water, according to a CalMatters comparison published Saturday.

Republican Steve Hilton has laid out a detailed agenda built on adding supply. Democrat Xavier Becerra, whom a September Public Policy Institute of California survey shows as the frontrunner, has published no specific water policies and declined repeated interview requests on the subject, CalMatters reported.

Hilton: build more

Hilton told CalMatters the state could have abundant water and blamed shortages on policy and mismanagement. He wants more storage, desalination and recycling, and state money to lower water bills. A 2024 plan he co-wrote with the California Policy Center put the cost as high as $150 billion, funded in part by redirecting 2% of the general fund from programs he calls wasteful.

He supports Sites Reservoir in Northern California and the Trump administration's proposal to raise Shasta Dam, and he would loosen endangered-species protections he says favor "a couple of fish species." He opposes the Delta tunnel, calling it "ridiculous, and unnecessary." A retired water manager quoted by CalMatters questioned the math: "There is plenty of water, there is no more cheap water."

Fishing and environmental groups and the Winnemem Wintu Tribe oppose the reservoir and dam raise.

Becerra: everyone at the table

Asked in writing, Becerra's campaign said he would bring all sides together to modernize infrastructure, guarantee safe and affordable drinking water and give farms and businesses reliable supply. At an April forum in Fresno, Becerra said the state must do better on storage, conveyance and conservation, and that the state should be "the big investor."

He has said groundwater rules may need trimming but are necessary, and that the Delta tunnel should not be ruled out before it is fully examined.

As attorney general, Becerra sued the first Trump administration more than 120 times, including over an earlier effort to raise Shasta Dam. Hilton said in their debate that those suits kept water from farmers; Becerra answered that California has a right to regulate its own water.

A former state water board chair told CalMatters she welcomes a governor who wants to hear from everyone first. A Pacific Institute co-founder was more skeptical, asking what would actually be offered at that table.

Polling this summer for the Association of California Water Agencies found majorities of Democrats, independents and Republicans more likely to back a candidate who prioritizes water reliability and affordability.

Sources

pleasantonweekly.com

Share

Reese Hardy

Reese Hardy writes about community life, schools, public safety, and local events in Pleasanton.

Related Stories

More in Sport