Pleasanton

PleasantonCA.city — Tri-Valley neighborhood news with hometown heart.

Back to Pleasanton

Two Pleasanton Churches Could Get Housing Zoning. Neither Has Asked to Build Anything Yet.

The City Council took up rezoning slivers of Trinity Lutheran on Hopyard Road and Rock Bible Church on First Street for up to 10 homes each. It is a Housing Element obligation, and the rezoning only creates an option.

Sasha Ortiz

September 1, 20262 min read

Zoning Blueprint - illustration, Jake Team LLC

The Pleasanton City Council on Tuesday considered rezoning small portions of two church properties to allow housing, a step the city is taking to keep its state-certified Housing Element inventory whole.

The two sites are Trinity Lutheran Church at 1225 Hopyard Road and Rock Bible Church at 4100 First Street. Under the proposal, about 0.66 acres of Trinity Lutheran's roughly 3.14-acre property and about 0.74 acres of Rock Bible Church's 1.88-acre property would be designated high-density residential, allowing up to 10 homes on each.

The outcome of Tuesday's council discussion had not been reported as of publication.

What the rezoning does, and does not do

The change would give each church the option to pursue a residential project on the rezoned portion. It does not approve one.

As of August, neither church had submitted a housing development plan, and any future project would still require its own separate city review and approval. Both churches have said they could continue their religious functions on the remainder of their property either way.

Why the city is doing this

Pleasanton adopted its Housing Element in 2023 to meet a state-mandated Regional Housing Needs Allocation of 5,965 units, 2,758 of them for lower-income households. City planners have said rezoning the two church sites would help the city meet its Housing Element implementation goal.

The city has also said it reached a settlement agreement with the Housing Action Coalition that requires it to consider rezoning additional sites to keep its housing inventory adequate on an ongoing basis.

Staff analyzed five sites from a list of 22 properties before recommending these two, weighing property size, location and suitability for infill development.

How it got here

The Planning Commission recommended the rezoning on June 24 by a 3-0 vote, with one commissioner absent and one recused.

Steve Wright, Trinity Lutheran's treasurer, told the commission the church was "very supportive of this opportunity to rezone a portion of the property." City planner Shweta Bonn said both churches had shown active interest in pursuing housing. No opposition was recorded at that hearing, and no representative of Rock Bible Church spoke.

What to watch

If the council approves the rezoning, the next step belongs to the churches. Either could file a plan for up to 10 homes on its rezoned portion, and that plan would come back to the city for review before anything is built.

Sources

Patch

pleasantonweekly.com

cityofpleasantonca.gov

Share

Sasha Ortiz

Sasha Ortiz covers Pleasanton city hall, the council, and county government.

Related Stories

More in California